I've been in IT for about 20 years, handling individuals and small businesses, so I have experience with a plethora of issues.
Frankly, it sounds like something is causing access point 2 to run at 10Mbits. Typically, this is a wiring issue, but there could be some rare compatibility issue here.
I can remote in and check ap2's config, but I'll end up calling you to run through some troubleshooting and ask questions.